Thursday, January 3, 2008

Lasting success in IRAQ?

The Long War Journal: The Real Surge



Written by DJ Elliott on November 23, 2007 10:44 AM to The Long War Journal


Available online at:
http://www.longwarjournal.org/archives/2007/11/the_real_surge.php


Iraq-IA-graduation-Besmaya-11202007.jpg
g>

Newly graduated soldiers hold up Iraq flags as they march during their
graduation ceremony at the Besmaya army camp in Baghdad November 18, 2007.
Reuters
os_ts/2007_11_20t041416_450x318_us_iran_iraq_usa;_ylt=AokOhT6A4SzQ4XQpy.mfvk
zKps8F> photo.

While the "surge" of five US brigades plus their accompanying support
elements, about 30,000 US troops total, is the main focus of commentators
when discussing the current situation in Iraq, the real surge in Iraq is
happening behind the scenes. The rapidly expanding
an_Transcript.pdf> Iraqi Army is where the real surge in forces is
occurring.

In November 2006, Prime Minister Maliki understated the real surge when he
announced the increase of the Iraqi Army beyond the subjective
counterinsurgency force. Maliki's originally announced plan
id=128> was an increase of the army by three divisions, five brigades, 20
battalions, and an Iraqi Special Operations Force (ISOF) battalion. He also
wanted to increase the manning of existing Iraqi units to 110 percent. At
that point, the Iraqi Army was 10 divisions, 35 brigades, 102 battalions,
and two ISOF battalions. Most Iraqi Army formations were only approximately
65 percent manned at that time.

Over the last year the Iraqi Army has grown to 12 divisions, 41 brigades,
123 battalions, and four ISOF battalions. This is a 20 percent increase in
units and a doubling of the ISOF. This does not include the three former
strategic infrastructure brigades (17 battalions) that have been transferred
to the Iraqi Army and are currently being retrained. While the Iraqi Army
officer and NCO ranks remain undermanned, the overall unit manning has grown
to 108 percent during that time. This does not mention the steadily
increasing Iraqi Army competence that can only come from combat and
counterinsurgency experience.

The newly formed Iraqi Army units over the past year include:



Chart showing the progression of the expansion of the Iraqi Army since 2006.

3-9 Tank Brigade - North Baghdad/Strategic Reserve (Deployed to Basrah)
4-9 Light Armored Cavalry Brigade- North Baghdad/Strategic Reserve (Stryker
training)
4-4 Brigade - Salahadin
2-14 Brigade - Basrah (originally 5-10 Brigade)
11th Division Headquarters - East Baghdad
3-11 Brigade - Sadr City (Graduated Besmaya on November 18)
2-11 Brigade - East Baghdad (Training at Besmaya)
14th Division Headquarters - Basrah
Two battalions of ISOF (Basrah Battalion and four separate companies)

By the time the US plans to reduce its combat forces to pre-surge levels
(July 2008), the real surge is planned to have increased the Iraqi Army to
13 divisions, 49 brigades, 154 battalions, and five or six ISOF battalions.
This includes finishing the retraining and equipping of the former SIBs
transferred to the Iraqi Army. The manning of the Iraqi Army is currently
planned to reach 120 percent of unit strength by July 2008. From the time
the US surge of only five combat brigades was announced to the time it ends,
the real surge will have increased the Iraqi Army field forces by 30 percent
in divisions, 40 percent in brigades, 50 percent in battalions, and 150
percent in ISOF. In addition the existing Iraqi Army combat unit manning
will have increased to 120 percent from the pre-surge level of approximately
65 percent.

The Iraqi Army will field the following units by July 2008:

4-3 Brigade - Southwest Ninawa
4-5 Brigade - Diyala
4-7 Light Armored Cavalry Brigade - Anbar (Rutbah)
3-14 Brigade - Basrah
4-14 Brigade - Basrah
12th Division Headquarters - Tikrit
1-12 Brigade - Western Kirkuk (retrained SIBs)
2-12 Brigade - Northern Salahadin (retrained SIBs)
3-12 Brigade - Southern Salahadin (retrained SIBs)
One or two more battalions of ISOF and ISOF Aviation Squadron

The US is considering plans to draw down to 10 combat brigades by early
2009. The Iraqi Army plans to continue growing to 13 divisions, 52 brigades,
162 battalions, and seven or eight ISOF battalions. This does not include
the additional fire support, logistics, and engineer battalions being formed
for each brigade. Part of that increase is the 33,000 Iraqi Army support
troops that was funded by the US
Emergency_Supplemental_Request_for_the_GWOT.pdf> FY07 Supplemental. These
additional 33,000 soldiers represent a 250 percent increase over the current
14,000 Iraqi Army support troops. This increased logistics support will
allow Iraqi Army units to operate independently and will release US
logistics units for redeployment.

The Iraqi Army will field the following units between July 2008 and early
2009:

4-12 Brigade - Salahadin
4-1 Brigade - Eastern Anbar (replacement for redesignated 4-11)
1-10 Brigade - Maysan (possibly DhiQar; replacement for redesignated 3-8)
One or two more battalions of ISOF
One fire support battalion per brigade
Finish adding the engineer regiments to the divisions (three battalions
each)

In 2009 the Iraqi Army plans to start forming the 13 divisional field
artillery regiments and their 39 subordinate field artillery battalions.

This is the real surge -- a surge in training and building of the Iraqi
Army. Security in Iraq improves with an increased long-term security
presence; a security presence that will increasingly be shouldered by Iraqi
troops. The five US surge brigades were not only brought in to buy the Iraqi
government time to sort out the political situation, they were brought in to
buy the Iraqi Army time to expand. The five US surge brigades are doing some
much needed housecleaning in Iraq's problem areas, freeing up Iraqi Army
formations to provide cadre for new forming units, and providing additional
training partners for the new Iraqi Army formations thus facilitating the
accelerated expansion. The Iraqi Army is replacing the US forces departing
Iraqi by the end of 2008 at rate of two Iraqi brigades for one US brigade.

While the surge brigades will eventually depart, the Iraqi Army is not
leaving Iraq.
Attachments:
untitled-1.2 8.4 k [ text/html ] Download | View
Iraq-IA-graduation-Besmaya-11202007.jpg 115 k [ image/jpeg ] Download | View
IA expansion-thumb.JPG

How badly Buckley buckles?

Dear Bill Buckley,

I have admired your Firing Lines and other contributions/blogs to our civilization for many years

BUT

became increasingly disappointed with your sagacity displayed a few days ago on the Charlie Rose show.

My sadness deepen'd as your opinion about the Iraq's liberation played DIRECTLY into the far left views of your host - a relentless brilliant critique,warrior and key player in the liberal wars against our President & his administration. To me you
appear to have been used as a willing tool by a clever, smiling adversary to fire
another cheap shot against President Bush.

I admired you and hoped you'd hold onto your STATESMANLIKE grand panoramic view of history - instead your hostility against Iraq's liberation and sceptimism about establishing a second democracy in the Middle-East sounds closer to alQaida
propaganda than an uttarance by America's senior respected Mr. Conservative.

YOU seem to have forgotten that the UN has passed some 16 resolutions against Saddam - each and every one ignored. This flagrant disregard of the UN threatened to undermine the entire structure of world order. The rule of law was in jeopardy. Bush stepped in when a seventeenth [or so] resultion was presented, passed and then ENFORCED by America. This not only temporarily saved a tottering world order's credibility but got riddance of one of the worst opressors I have known.

I know what I speak of -- I have witnessed personally the atrocities of the Nazis and the Soviets.

You appear to me so fossilized/devoted to your misguided loss of faith in America and the percieved failure in Iraq so devotedly wished by the Democrats AND your host Charlie Rose - that you dont appear to show even a glimmer of recognition that America WILL succeed in Iraq and elsewhere in the longlong war against Terror.

I speak with authority. I'm the adoped son of an Ambassador to the League of Nations who railed against its supine surrender to Hitler and el Duce in the 1930's. Dr. Eckhardt has forseen with absolute clarity that appeasement will lead to inevitable
war of the most hideous kind. .I was among those who suffered directly the dire consequences. He is my mentor.

Now I see with absolute clarity that continued appeasement of the Terrorists and undermining traitorously from the inside a la New York Times our determination to defeat Evil --- will lead to needless prolongation of our present war against the
Evil Forces of our planet.

I invite you to join in this struggle against evil! I trust this email is your wake-up call and that we can count on your immeasurable talents and prestige not to aid and abet the likes of Rose, but be in the forefront in our struggle against
history's greatest challange so far.

Sincerely

Douglass Montrose-Graem

Chairman Audit Sarasota Veterans Commission
CEO/Founder The TurnerMuseum
www.turnermuseum.org
Honored as one of "One Thousand Great Americans"
Author "I Delight to DO the WILL of GOD"
www.delightdelight.org
etc, etc.
Sarasota Florida